+90 (226) 811 29 28info@iscan.av.tr
Legal Information

When a Debtor Moves Assets Away: The Action to Annul Transactions, Insolvency Certificate and Time Limits (Enforcement Code Arts. 277–284)

Attorney Berk İşcan · 16 November 2026 · 8 min read

A debtor may have transferred or given away property to a relative before an attachment arrives. Article 277 and the following articles of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code (İİK) let the creditor have such transactions treated as void as against the creditor: the action to annul transactions (tasarrufun iptali davası). This article summarises who can bring the action, which transactions can be annulled, Art. 278 as amended by Law No. 7571, the time limits, and how the action differs from a sham-transaction (muvazaa) claim.

1. What is the action to annul transactions?

Under Art. 277 the purpose of the action is to have the transactions described in Arts. 278, 279 and 280 declared void. The transaction stays valid between the debtor and the other party but has no effect against the creditor. The Grand Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation explains that in an annulment action a validly made transaction is declared ineffective as to the claimant, whereas a sham-transaction claim asserts that the transaction was never really made (HGK, E.2017/1446, K.2021/65). The aim is to continue enforcement against the asset and collect the claim (17th Civil Chamber, E.2017/4972, K.2019/856).

2. Who can bring the action? The insolvency certificate

Under Art. 277(1) the action may be brought by any creditor holding a provisional or final insolvency certificate (aciz belgesi). The Court of Cassation treats this as a procedural requirement that the judge must examine on their own motion (17th CC, E.2016/3789, K.2019/2350; HGK, E.2017/2773, K.2021/987).

  • Final certificate: issued for the unpaid remainder if the claim was not fully collected in enforcement (Art. 143).
  • Provisional certificate: the attachment record drawn up when not enough assets are found (Art. 105) is accepted as having this effect (17th CC, E.2019/3522, K.2020/5176; 4th CC, E.2024/4853, K.2024/10239). Art. 278, as amended by Law No. 7571, also expressly refers to an "attachment record that has the nature of an insolvency certificate".

The Court of Cassation lists further conditions: the claimant's claim must be real, the enforcement proceedings against the debtor must be final, the transaction to be annulled must have been made after the debt in the proceedings arose, and a final or provisional certificate must exist (17th CC, E.2017/4972, K.2019/856). The reality of the claim is examined too: the defendant may argue and prove that the debt behind the certificate did not actually exist (HGK, E.2017/2773, K.2021/987). Where no attachment had been carried out against the debtor, the court could not find that insolvency existed (17th CC, E.2016/3789, K.2019/2350).

3. Which transactions can be annulled?

ArticleTransactionPeriod and condition
Art. 278Apart from customary gifts, gifts and transactions without considerationThe one year before the date on which the insolvency certificate (or an attachment record with that nature) was issued or bankruptcy was opened
Art. 279Voidness because of insolvency: by a debtor who is not paying debts, a pledge for an existing debt (unless security was previously promised), payment other than in money or usual means of payment, payment of a debt not yet due, a land-registry annotation to strengthen personal rightsWithin one year before attachment, insolvency or the opening of bankruptcy. The action is not heard if the beneficiary proves they did not know the debtor's situation
Art. 280Intent to harm: all transactions by a debtor whose assets do not cover their debts, made with intent to harm creditorsThe other party must have known, or the signs must have made it knowable; enforcement or bankruptcy proceedings must have been started against the debtor within five years of the transaction

Transactions treated as gifts (Art. 278)

  • Unless it is proved that they were made for a consideration matching the real value: transactions between the debtor and descendants and ascendants, blood relatives up to the third degree, relatives by marriage up to the third degree, adoptive parent and adopted child, persons living in a shared home, and the spouse (even if the marriage ended within the last year).
  • Unless proved otherwise, contracts in which the debtor accepted a very low price compared with the real value of what they gave. The Court of Cassation says mortgages and attachments registered on a property must be taken into account when judging whether the price was low (17th CC, E.2016/18200, K.2019/6136).
  • Unless an appropriate counter-performance is proved, life annuity, usufruct or care-until-death contracts.

Presumptions for intent to harm (Art. 280)

The debtor's spouse, descendants and ascendants, blood and in-law relatives up to the third degree, and adoptive parent or adopted child are presumed to know the debtor's situation; they can rebut this only as provided in the last paragraph of Art. 279. A person who takes over all or a significant part of a business or its stock in trade is presumed to know of the intent to harm creditors, and the debtor is presumed to have acted with that intent; the presumption can be rebutted only by proving that written notice or a public announcement was made at least three months before the transfer.

Art. 278 as amended by Law No. 7571

Article 278 was rewritten by Art. 2 of Law No. 7571 dated 24 December 2025 (Official Gazette of 25 December 2025). In the current text the look-back period for transactions without consideration is one year. Earlier Court of Cassation decisions refer to a two-year period under the old text (for example 17th CC, E.2019/3522, K.2020/5176). Which text applies to transactions made before the amendment must be examined separately under the entry-into-force and transitional provisions; this article does not address that question.

4. Time limit: five years from the transaction

Under Art. 284 the right to bring the action lapses five years after the date of the void transaction. In one case the Court of Cassation noted that the sale was made on 22.09.2008 and the action filed on 24.11.2014, and held that the action should have been dismissed as time-barred (17th CC, E.2016/18254, K.2019/5278). The period runs from the date of the transaction, not from when the claim arose, so it is important to establish that date from the land-registry record or the relevant document.

5. How is the action brought?

  • Competent court: the civil court of first instance (asliye hukuk mahkemesi) (5th CC, E.2023/11567, K.2024/2904).
  • Territorial jurisdiction: there is no special rule, so the general rule applies: the court where the defendant is domiciled. Even if the subject is immovable property, the action is personal; it may be brought where any one of the defendants is domiciled. Because jurisdiction is not mandatory, an objection must be raised in the statement of defence (20th CC, E.2019/5259, K.2019/7152).
  • Defendants (Art. 282): the debtor, those who dealt with the debtor or received payments from them, and their heirs; also third parties in bad faith. The action does not infringe the rights of good-faith third parties.
  • Procedure (Art. 281): the simple procedure applies. On the creditor's request the judge may order a precautionary attachment over the assets concerned; the need for and amount of security is set by the court. If any defendant pays the claimant's claim, the action is dismissed.

6. What happens if the action succeeds? (Art. 283)

The transaction is not cancelled in the land registry and the property does not go back to the debtor; the result operates as against the creditor. The claimant gains the power to collect through enforcement against the asset; if it is immovable property, they can ask for attachment and sale without the register entry in the third party's name having to be corrected. If the asset has left the third party's hands, the third party is ordered to pay in cash the value that replaced it, up to the claimant's claim. A good-faith donee only has to return what they still hold at the time of the action.

7. How it differs from a sham-transaction claim

If the debtor and a third party made a collusive transaction to prevent a claim from being paid, the transaction may be invalid for being a sham. The Court of Cassation holds that in a claim based on sham the claimant does not need to have started enforcement or obtained an insolvency certificate (HGK, E.2017/1446, K.2021/65; 17th CC, E.2016/18256, K.2019/4779). The right to bring an annulment action under Art. 277 ff. does not prevent a sham-transaction claim under the general provisions (17th CC, E.2016/18256, K.2019/4779). Which route fits depends on the facts and on what can be proved.

8. What should you do?

  • Make the enforcement final and, at the attachment stage, look into the debtor's assets (land registry, vehicles, bank accounts, claims against third parties). If not enough assets are found, the attachment record or the insolvency certificate for the unpaid remainder satisfies the procedural requirement.
  • Establish the type and date of the transaction: Arts. 278 and 279 use one-year periods; Arts. 280 and 284 use five years. Rights can be lost if time limits are missed.
  • Collect evidence: the land-registry record, the transfer price and market value gap, kinship or shared home between the parties, the debtor's debt position on the transfer date.
  • If the transfer needs to be stopped during the case, consider asking for a precautionary attachment under Art. 281.
  • For related topics see our articles on third-party ownership claims, removal of objection and the negative declaratory action and recovery of payment.
  • If you would like your file assessed, you can book an appointment or reach us on the contact page.

Related articles: Notice of attachment: seven days as a third party and Property that cannot be seized.

This article is prepared for general information and does not replace legal advice. Every file is different, and rights can be lost if time limits are missed.

This article is for general information only, it does not constitute legal advice.

Share:LinkedInXWhatsApp

Related articles